How to Calculate Payroll Taxes for Small Business

laptop computer with electronic receipt or financial transaction, online payment confirmation with credit card concept, vector illustration

Learning how to calculate payroll taxes for small business can be daunting. Accurate calculation of these taxes is not just a legal requirement; it’s an essential part of your organization’s financial health, which impacts everything from your bottom line to the overall satisfaction of your employees. If there are missteps when calculating payroll taxes, you can face penalties, interest, and unwanted IRS attention. Our expert guide will break down how to calculate payroll taxes for small business and provide you with a straightforward step-by-step approach. 

What are Payroll Taxes

Payroll taxes encompass the taxes employers and employees must pay based on wages and salaries. Payroll taxes include federal income taxes, Social Security and Medicare taxes (FICA taxes), and federal and state unemployment taxes. Each type of tax has its own calculation rules and payments, making understanding their distinctions imperative for business owners. 

Preparing to Calculate Payroll Taxes

Ensuring your business is prepared before diving into the payroll tax calculations is essential. This means obtaining an Employer Identification Number (EIN) from the IRS, setting up a compliant payroll system, and gathering the necessary documentation like W-4 forms for withholding allowances and I-9 forms for employment eligibility. Once you have these materials, you can learn how to calculate payroll taxes for small business. 

Step-by-Step Guide to Calculating Federal Payroll Taxes

As noted above, payroll taxes include various taxes that must be calculated correctly to avoid penalties. Below, we break down the multiple taxes to help you learn how to calculate payroll taxes for small business. 

Calculating Gross Pay

The foundation of payroll taxes is the gross pay for your employees for the pay period. Gross pay is not just their base salary but any overtime, bonuses, or taxable benefits. 

Withholding Income Taxes

Using the information employees provide on their W-4 forms and IRS tax tables; you can calculate the federal income tax to withhold for each employee in each pay period. The IRS provides annual updates to these tables that reflect changing tax rates or brackets. 

Calculating Social Security and Medicare Taxes

For 2023, the Social Security tax rate is 6.2% for employees and employers on earnings up to the taxable maximum of $147,000. The Medicare tax rate stands at 1.45% on all wages, with an additional 0.9% Medicare surtax for high earners. Multiply the applicable rate by each employee’s gross pay to determine the FICA taxes owed. 

Federal Unemployment Tax

Federal Unemployment Tax, also known as FUTA, funds workforce agencies and is paid by employees at a rate of 6% for the first $7,000 earned annually. However, businesses can receive a credit of up to 5.4% for state unemployment taxes paid, potentially reducing the FUTA rate to 0.6%. 

Calculating State and Local Payroll Taxes

State and local taxes vary widely, so it‘s imperative to consult your state’s Department of Revenue or a tax professional, like the ones at Canal HR, for specific rates and rules. These may include, but are not limited to, state income taxes, state unemployment taxes (SUTA), and other local taxes. 

Common Mistakes to Avoid 

A common mistake many individuals make when learning how to calculate payroll taxes for small business is misclassifying employees as independent contractors. This mistake can lead to significant tax implications and penalties. 

Additionally, failing to account for all taxable benefits or not keeping up to date with the changing tax laws can lead to inaccurate tax calculations, which brings additional penalties. 

Outsourcing Payroll Taxes

Many small and large businesses benefit from outsourcing their payroll taxes. Outsourcing not only takes the work off your plate but ensures compliance, so you won’t have any implications or penalties to deal with in the future. When you outsource to a PEO like Canal HR, our team of professionals will handle all the nuances of payroll taxes so you can focus on running your business instead of being bogged down with administrative tasks. 

Some of the benefits that we can provide to you and your business consist of the following: 

  • Reduced Payroll and Operational Costs: Outsourcing to a PEO can eliminate the need for an in-house team, saving your business money on salaries, onboarding, and training costs. Additionally, when you process payroll and print checks, reports, and other forms, you spend a large portion of your office resources, increasing your costs to replenish the goods. This is another area where Canal HR can help since we handle everything for you with our resources. 
  • Professional Dispute Handling: We have the experience and resources to handle any tax disputes and audits, providing your business with representation and advice should any issues arise. 
  • Advisory Role: Our team is prepared to provide valuable insights into payroll strategies, tax savings opportunities, and HR best practices. 
  • Advanced Technology: We use sophisticated payroll software and systems that may be too costly for some businesses, but by partnering with us, you can access that software alongside enhanced efficiency and security. 
  • Scalability: We can quickly scale our services to accommodate increased complexity and additional employees. If your business expands, we can handle it without the need for you to invest in new payroll or HR infrastructure. 

Our team is skilled in employee check administration and delivery; comprehensive payroll reports; W-2 filing; federal, state, and payroll tax calculations; payroll tax deposit due date tracking; changes in federal and state payroll tax rules and legislation monitoring; and more. Partnering with Canal HR saves you time and money and grants you access to our industry expertise. 

Never Wonder How to Calculate Payroll Taxes for Small Business by Partnering with Canal HR

Learning how to calculate payroll taxes for small business and then managing it for years to come is complex and time-consuming, but you don’t have to do it alone. Canal HR offers professional payroll services designed to meet your business’s unique needs, regardless of size. Contact us today to learn how we can help streamline your payroll processes, ensuring accuracy and compliance with all obligations and regulations. Explore our service and take the first step toward stress-free payroll management.